Why Some People Thrive Working From Home and Others Don’t

Remote work is not one thing. It is a set of conditions, and those conditions can help or hinder you.

Working from home can feel like freedom, or it can feel like being trapped inside your own to-do list. For one person, a quiet house and a long stretch of focus time is exactly what they needed to do their best work. For someone else, the same setup turns into drifting, lonely afternoons, constant snacking, guilt, and the strange feeling of being both always at work and never fully working.

When people talk about remote work, they often talk as if it is one thing. A perk. A problem. A trend. A personality type. But the truth is softer and more specific.

Some people thrive at home because the conditions suit them. Some people struggle at home because the conditions fight them.

Soft Productivity starts here. You do not need to become a different person to make remote work easier. You need to build kinder conditions that match your real needs, your real energy, and the kind of work you actually do.

🌷 Conditions matter

What Thriving At Home Really Means

Thriving does not mean you are always motivated. It does not mean your home office looks perfect. It does not mean you love every minute.

Thriving means you can do meaningful work without burning out. You can switch off at the end of the day. You feel steady enough inside your week that your life does not become chaos in a different outfit.

It is also worth saying this clearly. Working from home is not automatically better, and it is not automatically worse. Strong research suggests outcomes vary by people and context, and many organisations are finding hybrid can keep performance steady while improving retention. (Nature)


What It Is Not

It is not about being a better adult.

It is not about having more willpower.

It is not proof that you are disciplined, or that you are failing.

It is also not simply introverts thriving and extroverts suffering. Personality matters, but it is one piece of a bigger picture. Research has looked at how Big Five traits relate to remote work experiences like exhaustion, and how trait performance links can shift in remote settings. (ScienceDirect)

💗 Not a character test

The Four Conditions That Decide Whether You Thrive

When remote work goes well, it is usually because four conditions are in place. When it goes badly, one of these is missing.

Quick Self Check

  • Work Design
  • Home Environment
  • Boundary Control
  • Social And Emotional Fit

Work Design

Some jobs fit home better than others. If your work is independent, deep, and outcome-based, home can be a gift. If your work relies on quick back and forth, constant coordination, or rapid feedback loops, home can feel like friction all day. You end up in meetings to replace what used to happen naturally, and your attention gets sliced into tiny pieces.

This is why hybrid can work so well for many teams. Research from a large field experiment found that two days a week at home did not harm performance and improved retention. (Nature)

Soft Productivity insight. If your work is heavily collaborative, you can still work from home successfully, but you need a plan for communication that protects focus. Otherwise your day becomes a chain of interruptions that never lets you settle.

Home Environment

Some people have a quiet room, a door, and a chair that supports their body. Some people have a kitchen table, a laptop perched at the wrong height, and constant movement around them. Some people are caring for children, parents, or both.

This is not a small detail. A systematic review of remote working and health notes impacts that can include musculoskeletal issues, fatigue and stress, alongside potential benefits. (PMC)

Soft Productivity insight. You do not need a full home office to improve this. You need one supportive corner. One stable setup. One small signal that says, when I sit here, I am doing one thing.

Boundary Control

People who thrive at home often have clearer boundaries, even if their day is busy. They know when work starts, what work looks like, and when work ends. People who struggle at home often have blurred edges. They keep checking messages. They keep doing small tasks. They never fully arrive at work, and they never fully leave it.

The biggest remote work myth is that flexibility automatically creates balance. Flexibility can also create endlessness.

Soft Productivity insight. You do not need rigid rules. You need soft edges that still hold. A start anchor. A stop anchor. A small ritual that tells your mind, we are switching modes now.

Social And Emotional Fit

Some people get energy from quiet. Others need people around them to feel alive and motivated. Even people who enjoy solitude can struggle if they feel disconnected or unseen for long stretches.

That does not mean home is wrong for you. It means connection has to be designed, not left to chance.

Soft Productivity insight. Connection is not another task to add. It is part of your wellbeing system. When you feel alone, everything becomes harder, including work.


Personality Matters, But Not In The Simple Way People Say

Personality can shape how you experience remote work. For example, research has explored links between Big Five traits and remote work exhaustion. (ScienceDirect) It has also examined how remote settings can change the relationship between traits and self reported performance. (MDPI)

What matters is not labelling yourself. It is noticing your pattern.

If you are someone who needs external structure, home may feel too open. If you are someone who needs quiet to think, the office may feel too loud. If you are sensitive to social cues, home may feel calmer. If you rely on social energy, home may feel flat.

Soft Productivity insight. You can support any personality with the right scaffolding. The aim is not to force yourself into a version of work that drains you. The aim is to build a gentler shape around your reality.

✨ Notice your pattern

The Soft Productivity Map

If you are not thriving at home, ask which of these feels most true.

You Are Working, But Not Creating

Your day is full of messages, meetings, and admin. You do not get enough uninterrupted time to do the work that matters.

Soft fix. Protect one small focus block first, then build from there.

You Are Creating, But Burning Out

You can work deeply, but you never stop. You keep stretching the day, and your body is paying for it.

Soft fix. Add an end anchor and a true shut down.

You Are Free, But Floating

You have time, but you cannot start. You keep preparing, planning, and switching tasks.

Soft fix. Use one clear start cue and one tiny first step.

You Are Focused, But Lonely

You can work, but you feel isolated. Over time, motivation drops.

Soft fix. Add low effort connection points that feel natural.


Try This Today

Start Here In 10 Minutes

Pick one, not all.

  1. Make One Surface Work Only
    Clear a small area. Even a corner. This is your work signal.
  2. Write One Outcome For Today
    One sentence. What will exist by the end of the day that does not exist now.
  3. Create A Stop Anchor
    A short walk. Closing the laptop and putting it away. Changing clothes. Anything that marks the end.
  4. Fix One Physical Discomfort
    Raise your laptop. Use a cushion. Adjust your chair. Small changes matter for long days. (PMC)
  5. Send One Connection Message
    A quick voice note to a colleague. A check in with a friend. A tiny thread of human contact.

Keep This In Mind

  • You do not need to become a different person to make remote work easier.
  • The goal is kinder conditions that match your real needs and real energy.
  • Flexibility can create endlessness, so boundaries still matter.
  • Connection has to be designed, not left to chance.

If This Is Hard, Try This Instead

If your home life is busy, especially with children, stop aiming for the perfect remote day.

Aim for a steadier one.

Make your goal smaller.

  • A single focused block.
  • A single meaningful output.
  • A single end point.

If your day gets interrupted, you have not failed. You are living. Return to your next small step.

Soft Productivity is about returning, not controlling.

🌸 Return, gently

A Gentle Hybrid Reality Check

If working from home feels hard, it may not mean you should give it up. It may mean a blended approach would support you better, if that is possible. Research from a large scale experiment suggests hybrid with two days a week at home can keep performance stable while improving retention. (Nature)

There is also evidence that working from home patterns have stabilised after the pandemic, and that desire to work from home can be especially strong among women with children. (siepr.stanford.edu)

Soft Productivity insight. Your ideal setup can change by season. A baby season is not a deep work season. A caregiving season is not a maximal output season. Let your work shape match your life shape.


A Quick FAQ

Is working from home actually productive

It depends on the job and the setup. Research suggests hybrid schedules can maintain performance and can improve retention in some contexts. (Nature) OECD analysis also discusses telework with generally positive views from managers and workers, with variation by context and practice. (OECD)

Why do I feel more tired at home than in the office

Many people underestimate the cost of blurred boundaries, poor ergonomics, and being socially disconnected. Research reviews note possible physical and psychological health impacts, including fatigue and stress. (PMC)

I love the idea of home, but I keep procrastinating

That often points to a structure problem, not laziness. Create a start cue, reduce decisions, begin with a tiny first step.

What if my home is too noisy

Then the goal is not silence. The goal is a workable pocket. Noise cancelling headphones, a consistent time window, or a specific corner that signals focus can help.


Closing Thoughts

Some people thrive working from home because home gives them what they were missing. Quiet, autonomy, fewer interruptions, more time, more space to think.

Some people struggle because home takes away what supported them. Natural structure, social energy, clear boundaries, a clean separation between roles.

Neither makes you better. Neither makes you worse.

The question is not, am I the kind of person who can work from home.

The question is, what conditions help me do good work while still having a life that feels calm enough to live.

You are allowed to build that gently. You are allowed to revise it as your season changes. You are allowed to choose contentment over chaos, even in the way you work.

References

With softness and strength,

Vindya

Share Article:

Vindya Vithana

Writer

Soft Productivity is the name I’ve given to the way I try to live and work now, gently, clearly, and in a rhythm that fits real life. I used to believe the only way to make progress was to push harder.

Over time, and especially through motherhood, I realised I needed something kinder and more sustainable. Here, I share honest reflections and simple practices for those who want steady progress without burnout, and who want their days to feel calm, purposeful, and truly their own.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hello!

Soft Productivity is the name I’ve given to the way I try to live and work now, gently, clearly, and in a rhythm that fits real life. I used to believe the only way to make progress was to push harder.

Over time, and especially through motherhood, I realised I needed something kinder and more sustainable. Here, I share honest reflections and simple practices for those who want steady progress without burnout, and who want their days to feel calm, purposeful, and truly their own.

Recent Posts

  • All Post
  • Basics
  • Creativity
  • Lifestyle
  • Productivity
  • Relationships
  • Wellness
  • Work

My Life in Books

Reading has always been part of how I think, rest, and make sense of the world.
Here I share the books I read, what stays with me, and how I keep reading consistently in a full, lived-in life.

Edit Template

About

Soft Productivity is a gentler way to get meaningful work done without living in constant pressure. Fewer priorities, simple structure, and a pace you can keep. Practical tools, calm philosophy, and a return to contentment over chaos.

With softness and strength, Vindya

Recent Post

  • All Post
  • Basics
  • Creativity
  • Lifestyle
  • Productivity
  • Relationships
  • Wellness
  • Work